Skip to main content

Company Profile:

  • Industry: E-commerce (fashion)
  • Revenue: $8M/year
  • Employees: 45
  • Challenge: Over 30 SaaS tools, no centralized tracking

The Problem: Tool Sprawl Run Amok​

Like many fast-growing companies, this e-commerce brand added tools as needs arose—but never removed them when needs changed.

The wake-up call: Their CFO noticed software expenses had grown from $87K to $287K over 3 years (+230%) while revenue only grew 140%. Something was wrong.

When they ran their first comprehensive software ROI analysis, the discoveries were shocking:

What They Found​

Zombie Subscriptions ($67,000/year wasted):

  • 14 tools unused for 90+ days
  • 3 subscriptions for employees who left 6+ months ago
  • 5 "trial" subscriptions that auto-renewed and were forgotten

Example: Graphic design tool with 10 enterprise licenses at $55/month each = $6,600/year. Usage data showed only 2 licenses actively used. Waste: $5,280/year.

Redundant Tools ($45,000/year overlap):

  • 3 different project management tools (Asana, Monday, Trello)
  • 2 CRM systems (HubSpot + Salesforce)
  • 4 analytics platforms (Google Analytics 360, Mixpanel, Heap, Amplitude)
  • 2 email marketing tools (Klaviyo + Mailchimp)

Example: Keeping both HubSpot ($12K/year) and Salesforce ($29K/year) when sales team only used Salesforce. Waste: $12K/year.

Feature Over-Payment ($38,000/year):

  • Enterprise plans when Professional would suffice
  • Unlimited plans with usage at 15% of limit
  • Add-on features never configured or used

Example: Shopify Plus at $2,000/month vs. Advanced Shopify at $299/month. Company didn't use any Plus-exclusive features. Waste: $20,400/year.

Total Identified Waste: $150,000/year (52% of software budget)

What They Did​

Phase 1: Immediate Cuts (Week 1)

  • Canceled 14 unused tools → $67K saved
  • Removed zombie user licenses → $8.4K saved
  • Total: $75,400 saved in 7 days

Phase 2: Consolidation (Weeks 2-6)

  • Kept Salesforce, cut HubSpot → $12K saved
  • Consolidated to Asana only → $16K saved
  • Kept Google Analytics, cut 3 others → $17K saved
  • Total: $45K saved over 6 weeks

Phase 3: Right-Sizing (Weeks 7-12)

  • Downgraded Shopify Plus to Advanced → $20.4K saved
  • Reduced design tool licenses 10 → 3 → $5.3K saved
  • Switched email tool to appropriate tier → $4.8K saved
  • Total: $30.5K saved over 6 weeks

The Results​

Year 1 Impact:

  • Eliminated: $150,900 in wasteful spend
  • Reinvested: $42,000 in high-ROI tools (Klaviyo advanced features, Shopify apps)
  • Net savings: $108,900 (38% budget reduction)
  • Team productivity: Increased 23% (fewer tools = less context switching)

CFO Quote: "We thought we needed all these tools to grow. Turns out we were drowning in them. Cutting 40% of our software actually made us more efficient."

Case Study #2: SaaS Company Proves Salesforce ROI, Saves Budget from Cuts​

Company Profile:

  • Industry: B2B SaaS
  • Revenue: $2M ARR
  • Employees: 25
  • Challenge: CFO demanded 20% software budget cut

The Problem: Defending Software Investment​

During a budget crunch, the CFO issued a mandate: "Cut 20% from software expenses across the board—no exceptions."

This would mean:

  • Reducing Salesforce licenses
  • Cutting HubSpot features
  • Downgrading analytics tools
  • Eliminating "nice to have" productivity tools

The VP of Sales knew this would hurt revenue but had no data to prove it. Every tool seemed important, but which ones actually mattered?

What They Did​

Instead of blanket cuts, they ran a comprehensive software ROI analysis connecting:

  • Software costs (QuickBooks)
  • Deal outcomes (Salesforce)
  • Marketing pipeline (HubSpot)
  • Time tracking (internal data)

The analysis revealed dramatic differences in tool performance:

What They Found​

Top Performers (>1000% ROI):

Salesforce:

  • Cost: $45K/year
  • Attributed revenue: $980K in closed deals
  • ROI: 2,078%
  • Cutting this would cost $980K in revenue to save $9K

HubSpot Marketing:

  • Cost: $18K/year
  • Pipeline generated: $425K (23% close rate = $97K expected revenue)
  • ROI: 2,261%
  • Cutting would cost $97K revenue to save $3.6K

Stripe:

  • Cost: $12K/year (processing fees)
  • Revenue processed: $1.2M
  • ROI: 9,900%
  • Non-negotiable infrastructure

Bottom Performers (<50% ROI):

Project Management Tool:

  • Cost: $8K/year
  • Revenue correlation: 0%
  • Used by: 40% of team
  • Safe to cut or downgrade

Secondary CRM:

  • Cost: $15K/year
  • Overlap with Salesforce: 95%
  • Active users: 3 of 25
  • Pure waste, eliminate immediately

Underutilized Design Tools:

  • Cost: $22K/year (10 licenses)
  • Active usage: 2 licenses
  • Downgrade to 3 licenses, save $17.6K

The Negotiation​

Armed with data, the VP of Sales met with the CFO:

VP: "Here's the 20% cut: $49,600/year. But none of it touches our revenue-generating tools."

Proposed cuts:

  • Eliminate duplicate CRM: $15,000
  • Downgrade design licenses: $17,600
  • Cut project tool: $8,000
  • Consolidate communication tools: $9,000
  • Total: $49,600 (20.8% of $238K budget)

Proposed expansions:

  • Add Salesforce Einstein AI: +$12,000 (expected +$340K pipeline)
  • Upgrade HubSpot tier: +$8,000 (expected +$85K pipeline)
  • Total reinvestment: $20,000

Net budget change: -$29,600 (12.4% reduction)

The Results​

CFO approved the data-driven plan over blanket cuts.

6-month outcomes:

  • Software budget: Down 12.4% ($29.6K saved)
  • Revenue: Up 27% ($540K increase)
  • Sales cycle: Down 18% (Salesforce Einstein impact)
  • Marketing ROI: Up 34% (HubSpot optimization)

CFO Quote: "This is how budget decisions should be made—with data, not guesses. We saved money AND grew faster."

Case Study #3: Professional Services Firm Avoids $25K Migration Mistake​

Company Profile:

  • Industry: Professional services
  • Employees: 50
  • Challenge: Considering switch from QuickBooks to Xero

The Problem: Migration Hype vs. Reality​

The operations manager heard great things about Xero: "Better UI, more features, lower cost!"

On paper, it looked like a clear win:

  • QuickBooks: $6,000/year
  • Xero: $4,200/year
  • Apparent savings: $1,800/year

Before committing, they ran a comprehensive software ROI analysis including migration costs:

What They Found​

Total Cost of Migration:

One-time costs:

  • Data migration: $8,000 (professional service)
  • Chart of accounts rebuild: $2,000 (internal time)
  • Historical data cleanup: $2,000

Subtotal one-time: $12,000

Ongoing costs:

  • Xero subscription: $4,200/year
  • Missing integrations (3 tools): $8,000/year for new connectors
  • Retraining (40 hours × $75/hour): $3,000 first year

Subtotal Year 1: $27,200 Subtotal Year 2+: $12,200/year

QuickBooks actual cost: $6,000/year

ROI Analysis​

Year 1:

  • Cost to stay (QuickBooks): $6,000
  • Cost to switch (Xero): $27,200
  • Loss: -$21,200

Year 2:

  • Cost to stay: $6,000
  • Cost to switch: $12,200
  • Loss: -$6,200

Breakeven: Year 14 (if integration costs never improved)

The Decision​

They stayed with QuickBooks and instead:

  • Invested $3,000 in QuickBooks Advanced features
  • Improved existing integrations: $2,000
  • Training on unused features: $1,000

Total investment: $6,000 (one-time)

Result: 40% reduction in invoicing time, 15-day improvement in payment cycles, same annual cost structure.

CFO Quote: "We almost spent $25K to make our life worse. The ROI analysis saved us from an expensive mistake."

The Pattern: Data Beats Intuition​

All three companies share a common pattern:

Before ROI analysis:

  • Decisions based on vendor promises
  • No visibility into actual usage
  • Costs growing faster than value
  • Tool choices based on "what we heard was good"

After ROI analysis:

  • Data-driven decisions with clear ROI
  • Immediate identification of waste
  • Strategic reinvestment in proven tools
  • Measurable impact on bottom line

Total savings across 3 companies: $163,500 in Year 1

Run Your Own Software ROI Analysis​

You likely have similar opportunities hiding in your software stack:

  • Zombie subscriptions (average company has $28K worth)
  • Redundant tools (22% average overlap)
  • Feature over-payment (15-30% typical waste)

Don't guess—measure.

Download our free automated software ROI calculator: software-roi-calculator-production.yaml

It connects to your Salesforce, QuickBooks, HubSpot, Stripe, and other tools to calculate real ROI using your actual data—just like these three companies did.

Setup: 15 minutes | Results: Immediate | Cost: Free

Full guide: Software ROI Calculator Documentation

Find your $100K. Your CFO will celebrate.